Observation peer review

Peer Review

  • What are the author’s overall impressions for this topic? What evidence do they use to support this impression? On the author’s paper, squiggly underline any points that don’t add to or support these impressions.




  • What is the author’s organizational structure for this topic? Bullet point the different sections.  How effective is this structure?





  • Did the author include vivid descriptions?   List three details that the author included.





  • What is one thing this paper did very well?




  • What is one thing the author may need to revise before turning this in?




  • What is one question you still have after reading this piece?