Peer edit

  • Describe the problem being described.  Do you have any questions about the situation?

  • What is the solution proposed?  Include details of the solution.  Does the paper provide enough details?



  • Identify the reasons supporting the solution.  Is sufficient evidence provided to support each reason? Explain.

  • What concerns, questions, or opposing views does the author discuss?  How does the author respond? Is the response convincing?

  • Check the author’s citations and Works Cited page.  Are the formatted correctly?

  • What is one thing this paper did very well?

  • What is one thing the author may need to revise before turning this in?